When Cheating Pays, We All Lose.


As an Arsenal fan, I cannot pretend to be an entirely neutral observer of the Manchester City debacle. But the findings against the club raise questions that reach well beyond football fandom. They concern how society define success, what it is prepared to overlook, and whether the rules still mean the same thing for everyone.
This week the Premier League announced that an independent commission had found Manchester City guilty of financial breaches between 2009 and 2018. The findings concern arrangements used to inflate revenue and reduce costs. City disputes the findings and intends to appeal and sanctions will be considered separately. To be clear, this is a sporting regulatory ruling and not a criminal fraud conviction, and the final verdicts are all pending.
Even with those distinctions, the case raises and uncomfortable question. How much does the way success is achieved matter once the trophies have been lifted, the money has been made, and the winners have become powerful?
We live in a society that celebrates outcomes. We admire wealth, reward growth and give successful people a platform to explain how everyone else should follow their example. Yet we spend far less time asking if those outcomes were fairly achieved, who paid the price, or whether the same opportunity existed for people who followed the rules. Over and over again we find that wealth and success is often the result of cheating and fraud.
There is nothing wrong with ambition or wealth. I have spent my career helping businesses grow and connect with capital. But wealth alone tells us very little about judgment, character, integrity, or the value someone has created. A large fortune deserves scrutiny as well as admiration, particularly when its owner presents it as proof of personal virtue.
My concern is that we are becoming too comfortable separating success from conduct. If someone wins often enough, becomes rich enough or attracts a loyal enough following, criticism starts to look like jealousy. Questions about integrity become an attack on the institution, the political party or the person we have chosen to support.
Football makes that instinct easy to see. Supporters have a deep emotional investment in their clubs, and nobody wants their memories called into question. But the same instinct can shape our response to government and business. We excuse conduct from our own side that we would condemn immediately from someone else.
That creates a dangerous set of incentives. When the benefits of breaking the rules are substantial and the consequences appear distant, uncertain or affordable, misconduct can start to look like a sensible calculation. The person who refuses to participate risks being treated as naïve.
Delay matters too. Accountability delivered years later may struggle to repair the damage. A competitor may already have lost an opportunity, an investor may have lost savings, or an honest employee may have left rather than accept what was happening. A penalty can establish responsibility without making those people whole.
This is why enforcement serves a purpose beyond punishing an individual offender. It tells everyone else whether the standards are real. If powerful organizations can treat penalties as a manageable expense, the wider message is that compliance is optional for those who can afford the consequences.
In markets, that message is particularly corrosive. Investors commit money based on information they cannot fully verify themselves. They rely on accounts, disclosure, boards, auditors and regulators. When those safeguards fail, the damage can spread beyond the company involved because investors begin questioning whom else they can trust.
For an international company trying to attract new shareholders, credibility is already a challenge. Investors may be unfamiliar with its home market, management team and legal system. They need reasons to believe both the business opportunity and the information used to describe it.
That is central to how I think about Crossbridge’s work. Helping a company reach international investors means helping it become understandable, accessible and credible. Greater visibility carries a responsibility to give investors an honest picture of what they are buying.
A listing, a research report or a polished investor presentation can introduce a business to a wider audience. The relationship that follows depends on whether management delivers accurate information, acknowledges risks and keeps its commitments. Promotion creates expectations that the company must be prepared to meet.
Boards should therefore ask harder questions while things are going well. They should understand where revenue comes from, examine transactions involving connected parties and challenge explanations that seem designed to avoid scrutiny. Strong results are a reason to understand the business more deeply, especially when executive rewards depend on those results.
Companies also reveal their standards through how they handle disappointment. Management should explain a missed target clearly, correct an error promptly and allow employees to raise concerns without fear. Investors can assess a difficult quarter. They have a much harder time assessing a leadership team that keeps changing the story.
None of this requires companies to abandon ambition. It requires them to pursue growth in a way that can withstand scrutiny and demonstrates integrity. Leaders set that standard through the behavior they reward, the questions they welcome and the consequences they impose when someone crosses a line.
I want to see companies succeed, markets grow and investors discover opportunities they might otherwise miss. But lasting success needs a foundation people can trust. Whether we are looking at a football club, our government or a public company, how the result was achieved must be as important as the result itself.




Comments